Based on Reddit discussions, travel forums, and local blogs.
Locals and travelers praise Sheridan for its authentic western character—historic bars and shops, quality museums (Brinton, Trail End), a growing local food/beer scene, and outstanding nearby outdoor opportunities (Tongue River Canyon, Bighorn National Forest). Common caveats: watch seasonal road closures for mountain drives, expect crowds during rodeo season, and take typical backcountry precautions (wildlife, rattlesnakes, poison ivy, limited cell service).
The Mint Bar
Overall sentiment: mixed
Iconic classic cowboy bar on Main Street—stop for the atmosphere (taxidermy, rodeo photos) rather than fine dining. Expect a small, often-crowded local vibe and variable service from bartenders.
"Love the Mint Bar…"
"I had my first legal drink at this bar 😁❤️"
Sources: reddit.com · tripadvisor.com
King's Saddlery & Museum
Overall sentiment: positive
Authentic western tack shop with a large Don King saddle collection, rope/saddle demos and upstairs museum rooms with historic photos. Plan 45–90 minutes, check opening hours, and note the museum often operates on an honor-donation basis.
"Western history buffs will like this!"
Sources: tripadvisor.com
The Brinton Museum / Quarter Circle A Ranch
Overall sentiment: positive
Highly regarded Western and Native American art collection in a striking ranch setting with Bighorn views. It's a short drive out of town—consider paying for the ranch/house tour and check seasonal hours.
"The Brinton Museum is one of the best museum we have been to in America."
Sources: tripadvisor.com
Trail End / John B. Kendrick Mansion
Overall sentiment: positive
Historic house museum with period furnishings on Main Street—good short cultural stop for early-20th-century Wyoming history. Check admission (resident vs. non-resident), tour availability and be aware of some accessibility constraints (strollers, etc.).
"Wonderful historic site"
"Interesting walk back in time."
Sources: tripadvisor.com
Tongue River Canyon / North & South Tongue River
Overall sentiment: mixed
Highly recommended by locals for hiking, fishing and dramatic limestone canyon scenery. Bring appropriate footwear, bug protection and expect limited cell coverage; beware poison ivy, rattlesnakes, scorpions and that some sections require hiking-in rather than drive-up access.
"Tongue River Canyon is good."
"Tongue River Canyon ... is home to tons of Poison Ivy ... Diamondback Rattlesnakes (a metric shitload of rattlesnakes) ..."
Sources: reddit.com · reddit.com
Bighorn National Forest & scenic drives
Overall sentiment: positive
Top outdoor draw near Sheridan for scenic drives, trailheads, waterfalls (e.g., Shell Falls), horseback riding and wildlife viewing. Mountain roads are seasonal or rough in places—check road/opening status and be prepared for changing weather.
"Many forum threads and travel pages list the Bighorns as the top outdoor draw — scenic drives, trailheads, waterfalls (Shell Falls area), horseback and wildlife viewing."
"Visitors recommend taking US-14/US-16 up into the mountains for day hikes, overlooks and fishing."
Sources: sheridanwyoming.org · tripadvisor.com
Black Tooth Brewing
Overall sentiment: positive
Local craft brewery praised for beers like Wagon Box Wheat and Saddle Bronc Brown; the taproom and patio are popular. Beer is the main draw—expect generally good beer with occasional inconsistent service and state age rules to consider.
"If you like beer, definitely stop here!"
Sources: tripadvisor.com · wanderlog.com
Kendrick Park / downtown walking & public art
Overall sentiment: positive
Relaxed downtown park with a band shell, carved-tree sculptures and a small animal exhibit; downtown Sheridan features public art, galleries and boutiques. Expect big crowds and parking challenges during summer events like concerts and rodeo week.
"Locals recommend Kendrick Park for relaxed afternoons, the band shell, carved-tree sculptures, and a small animal exhibit (elk/buffalo)."
Sources: sheridanwyoming.org