Sheridan’s Main Street still hums with cowboy boots and Bighorn Mountain views, and its eateries lean toward hearty diners and relaxed downtown spots. Locals recommend Smith Alley Brewing, Silver Spur and Powder River Pizza for everyday meals, and Frackelton’s or Rib & Chop House for nicer nights—just check hours and recent reviews.
Based on Reddit discussions, travel forums, and local blogs.
Locals and visitors consistently recommend a mix of hearty diners and casual downtown spots in Sheridan — standout everyday picks include Silver Spur, Midtown, Java Moon and Smith Alley, while Frackelton’s and Rib & Chop House are frequent choices for nicer nights out. Common caveats are early/limited hours, occasional service/quality variability, and a few pricier favorites, so check hours and recent reviews before you go.
Overall sentiment: mixed
Local go-to for nicer dinners and creative, higher-end dishes (steaks, lobster ravioli, brussels sprouts); lively downtown vibe. Reservations recommended; some reviewers note slow service and occasional inconsistency.
"Frackelton’s maybe?"
Sources: tripadvisor.com · tripadvisor.ca · reddit.com
Overall sentiment: mixed
Popular brewpub with in-house beers, elevated pub menu and a roomy Main Street patio — a top casual downtown pick for burgers. Watch for price/service variation on third-party sites.
"I’ve always had a very good burger at Smith Alley Brewing on Main."
Sources: smithalleybrewingwy.com · smithalleybrewingwy.com · reddit.com
Overall sentiment: mixed
Long-standing local pizza spot known for wood-fire pies and distinctive specialty pizzas (Taco Pizza, German, Cowpoke) and a kid-friendly arcade. Praised for flavor but noted by some as pricey.
"Powder river pizza has killer wood fire pizzas."
"A fair warning, however: Powder River Pizza is egregiously expensive."
Sources: powderriverpizzawy.com · powderriverpizzawy.com · reddit.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Classic, old-school diner prized for huge portions and hearty breakfasts (cinnamon rolls, saddle-blanket pancakes, green-chile breakfasts); a must-stop for morning comfort food. Can be busy and has early closing hours.
"Silver Spur in Sheridan. Best diner in the country."
Sources: reddit.com · wanderlog.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Reliable local tavern known for a consistently good burger and classic American bar food — a casual favorite for dinners. Typical tavern environment; some find price/value varies.
"The Pony Bar and Grill is really good, I always thought their burger was the best in town."
Sources: tripadvisor.com · reddit.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Popular breakfast/lunch café with made-from-scratch sandwiches, burritos and coffee; affordable, fast service — a dependable daytime spot. Note limited breakfast/lunch hours.
"the BEST lattes and chicken quesadillas in Sheridan!"
Sources: midtownsheridan.com · tripadvisor.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Longstanding downtown coffee shop and gathering place known for scratch-made pastries and signature cinnamon rolls; two locations and strong community vibe. Some mixed reviews on service/consistency.
"Java Moon is the best coffee shop in Sheridan hands-down!"
Sources: javamooncoffee.com · javamooncoffee.com · tripadvisor.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Downtown gastropub popular for brunch, pizzas, craft cocktails, live music and a lively patio; good for groups and late-night hangouts (indoor golf simulator, games). If you want quiet dining, pick elsewhere; check event/brunch hours.
"Its brunch ‘to die for’ (creative items like breakfast pizza, bombolini)."
Sources: thewarehousegastropub.com · tripadvisor.com · traveltasteandtour.com
Overall sentiment: mixed
Known for inventive, offbeat menu items (donut burger, massive sandwiches) and large portions — a local favorite for creative brunch/lunch. Frequently inconsistent hours and service; flavors and portions can be polarizing.
"Their hours are frustratingly undependable, despite what’s posted. BUT it’s worth the wait if you can get in."
Sources: tripadvisor.com · downtownsheridan.org
Overall sentiment: mixed
Common pick for steakhouse meals — steaks, ribs and hearty American fare in a modern-rustic setting. Generally well-regarded but some reviewers note variability over time; check recent reviews for the latest impressions.
"Wow! Excellent meal!"
Sources: tripadvisor.com · ribandchophouse.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Traditional comfort-café menu with generous portions; solid choice for breakfasts and casual daytime meals.
"crispy hash browns and tasty bacon."
Sources: tripadvisor.com
Hours, directions, and contact info for restaurants in Sheridan.
3 S Gould St, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Informal restaurant & bar serving classic American fare, with seasonal outdoor seating.
Open now
847 N Main St, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Chophouse chain serving aged steaks, seafood, slow-cooked ribs & beer in a relaxed, casual setting.
Open now
2208 Coffeen Ave, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Seattle-based coffeehouse chain known for its signature roasts, light bites and WiFi availability.
Open now
1242 E Brundage Ln, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Gas-station & convenience store chain, serving drinks & snacks from burritos to frozen yogurt.
Open now
151 N Main St, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Old-school saloon serving cocktails & beers amid nostalgic photos, cattle brands & taxidermy.
Open now
1319 Coffeen Ave, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Fast-food burger chain serving sides such as chili & baked potatoes.
Closed
1373 Coffeen Ave, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Kid-friendly chain known for baked goods, breakfasts & other standards in dinerlike digs.
Open now
170 N Main St, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Panini, soups & salads served in a relaxed, lofty setting with an espresso bar & patio tables.
Open now
2146 Coffeen Ave, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Classic, long-running fast-food chain known for its burgers & fries.
Open now
55 N Main St, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Buzzy haunt in a historic building with select New American fare, original martinis & Sunday brunch.
Closed
