Based on Reddit discussions, travel forums, and local blogs.
Locals and travelers generally praise Livingston for its mix of casual beer-garden and food-truck options, creative breakfast spots, solid Italian and a few standout dinner rooms with great views. Common caveats are seasonal crowds, long lines at popular casual spots, variable service at busy times, and that some venues (Bistro/Campione/Yellowstone Valley Grill) benefit from reservations.
Neptune’s Taphouse & Eatery
Overall sentiment: positive
Lively outdoor beer garden with local beers on tap and rotating food trucks (notably MOSHI). Casual, good value in nice weather; check which food truck is scheduled.
"MOSHI FOOD TRUCK! … Parked at Neptunes L street location brewery in the back of their beer garden. The food is TASTY TASTY TASTY … HIGHLY RECCOMEND IT."
Sources: tripadvisor.com · reddit.com
Campione
Overall sentiment: positive
Higher-end Italian in downtown Livingston known for scratch cooking, house-made pastas and creative Roman comfort dishes. Popular for dinner—reserve during busy season.
"Everything was homemade and everything was delicious."
Sources: tripadvisor.com · eatcampione.com
Mark’s In & Out
Overall sentiment: mixed
Nostalgic seasonal drive-in famous for cheap burgers and thick milkshakes—classic local institution. Expect long lines in summer and split opinions on portion size/seasoning; be prepared to wait.
"As close as you'll get to In‑N‑Out in MT."
"Marks is the most overrated burger spot I've ever visited in my life. If you want to fight for nonexistent parking … stand in line outside for an under seasoned slider …"
Sources: tripadvisor.com · montanatalks.com · reddit.com
Faye’s Café
Overall sentiment: positive
Playful, highly personalized breakfasts and brunch in the Shane Lalani Center with a strong local/arts vibe and friendly owner/chef. Fans call it a highlight—contact ahead for serious allergies; ordering is often via text.
"This is the best place! Creativity abounds — the food, the menu, including the environment."
Sources: tripadvisor.com · sarahfayemontana.com
Murray Block (Murray Bar / 2nd Street Bistro / Gil's Goods)
Overall sentiment: mixed
Historic block offering a divey, music-filled bar (Murray), a fine-dining option (2nd Street Bistro), and casual pizza/coffee/bar food (Gil's). Great for atmosphere and live music; Murray can be noisy and Bistro may require reservations.
"be sure to get a drink at the Murray, Anthony Bourdain's favorite american bar."
Sources: murrayblock.com · tripadvisor.com · reddit.com
Katabatic Brewing Company
Overall sentiment: positive
Cozy downtown taproom with local craft beers, dog-friendly atmosphere and live music nights. Food is usually provided by a neighboring Mexican partner or pop-up vendors.
Sources: katabaticbrewing.com · visitmt.com
Pickle Barrel
Overall sentiment: positive
Regional favorite for big, hearty sub sandwiches—good quick lunch option. Popular spots can see slow service or occasional order mixups during busy times.
Sources: picklebarrelmt.com · tripadvisor.com
The Mint Bar & Grill
Overall sentiment: mixed
Neighborhood pub recommended for steaks and burgers with a friendly local vibe. Can get loud and crowded on weekends and service speed may vary.
Sources: tripadvisor.com · themintbarandgrill.com
Yellowstone Valley Grill
Overall sentiment: positive
Dining room with Yellowstone River and mountain views, recommended for special dinners and standout dishes (tenderloin, braised short ribs). Can be pricey, dining room comfort varies and reservations are advised.
"Hands down the best tenderloin I've had in Montana in over 10 years."
Sources: tripadvisor.com
Old Saloon (Emigrant / Paradise Valley)
Overall sentiment: positive
Historic saloon about 15–20 minutes south of Livingston with live music and an authentic western atmosphere—visitors often go for the ambience and summer concerts as much as the food.
Sources: themanual.com